Is my employer required to furnish pay stubs that I lost upon my request?

i FOUND THAT ON AT LEAST 5 OCCASIONS i WAS PAYED OVERTIME HOUR IN REGULAR HOURS i GAVE MY SUPERVISORS COPIES AND ENDED UP LOSING MOST OF MY PAY STUBS SO I DONT KNOW HOW MANY TIMES THEY DID THIS AND MY JOB WON'T CORRECT THE ERROR WITH OUT THEM AND WILL NOT GIVE ME COPIES OF THEM WHAT CAN i DO?